|
|
YourSite
|
 |
Welcome to Terengganu!! The Orgainsing Committee wishes the riders, grooms, Chef d' Equipes and Officials who have arrived in Terengganu a warm welcome. It feels great to finally see people from all around the world gathered here in the Terengganu International Endurance Park (TIEP) for the FEI WEC 2008.
|
 ·
 ·
 ·
 ·
 ·
 ·
 ·
 ·
 ·
 ·
 ·
 ·
|
  |
|
|
Aug 22 2007, 03:07 PM
|
Advanced Member
  
Group: AHSBA Member
Posts: 4,766
Joined: 8-September 06
From: Beannacht Arabian Ranch, TX
Member No.: 126


|
QUOTE (Megs @ Aug 22 2007, 02:53 PM)  Are french arabians a new thing? I have read as much as I can but I am not finding much as far as some history on this particular type. They say they are bred particularly for the track, and that so far people are really liking crosses between french stallions and domestic mares.
Anythoughts on this? I've never heard of a french arabian until I started doing my racing homework a while back, but still haven't gained much insight. Eeehhhh, sorta/kinda new. I think I will defer to far more knowledgeable folks than myself - folks such as Dan Woods, Jeff Wintersteen, Marsha Parkinson(stadnini koni), Carolyn Gipson(missmagus), and Esta (ebbsaffyre) to better comment upon the racing world. I have seen quite a few of the French breds and read much about their race track success but know very little more. Race folks? Fire away... Cyclone
--------------------
Beannacht Arabian Ranch
Pure Polish working western and sport horse prospects.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Aug 22 2007, 05:07 PM
|
Advanced Member
  
Group: Premium Member
Posts: 587
Joined: 12-June 07
From: Elizabeth, CO
Member No.: 1,167


|
Since I was mentioned I will throw in my two cents. I think it is important to mention a bias from the get go, in that I am not a huge fan French horses in general, but certainly conceed they have had a significant impact in the US, and dominant in the Middle East. As of July 2007, two out of the top five sires in the US are imported French stallions.
The controversy which has been hinted at in previous posts, is the discernable like of type in most French bred horses. This is not something new, when the first French horses first arrived in Poland in 1929 their notable lack of type and beauty was a cause of concern despite their superior racing ability. Consequently, the Society of Arabian Horse Breeders ruled that the French horses could not compete in the Classic races for fear of compromising their prized “Polish” look. More recently when I was in Poland in 2004 I spent some time chatting with a breeder from Iraq (yes Iraq!), he also made a comment about the French horses lack of type, and whether they were purebred.
In the defense of the French horses, their proponents maintain that their lack of type is due to the breeding program was focused entirely on racing, where with the Polish program racing was only a component to test courage, soundness, etc. Certainly there can be some validity to the argument. It should not be surprising to have the "purebred" issue in racing because Arabians are just not as fast as TB's or QH's, so when speed is the only measurement and any horse is considerable faster and less Arabian looking rumors will fly. Obviously DNA has eliminated this, but some maintain the damage is already done before DNA.
From a personal perspective, French horses are here to stay. Some are very good, but so are the domestic and Polish horses. A good Polish horse will beat a bad French horse any day of the week. DA Adioas, a PP stallion recently retired as the winningest US race horse of all time, a majority of his career was spent battling the "French invasion". As a huge generalization, I find soundness more of an issue in French horses than other strains, not surprising if speed is the only measurement for breeding.
Jeff
--------------------
Bob, Bonnie & Jeffrey Wintersteen Wintersteen Arabians 
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
|
  |
2 User(s) are reading this topic (2 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

Similar Topics
Similar Topics

Similar Topics
|